Over half a year ago now, I posted this. At the bottom, I said I was going to read up on feminism - I didn't want to label myself one until I knew what I was believing in. Getting Tumblr, in July some time, sort of assured me that I was definitely a feminist. I've still got A LOT to learn, and I find it hard to be 'learning' without people thinking you are the ultimate epitome of a misandrist or whatever if you were to write something you wanted to be informed upon. I'm in a feminist group on Facebook, and about a month ago now, Ophelia and i were discussing how we were scared to post stuff, in case we may have been wrong or ill informed or something, and be perceived as sexist or 'not a proper feminist' for doing so. I am still relatively young and although feeling as though I'm a way better person for being a feminist, I know I need to learn that feminism is a process, and I also know that I feel that picking up the label overnight can seem sort of daunting. I leave myself wondering whether I'm 'worthy' of the 'label', because I know I'm not an activist or clued up on everything. Is this a silly thing to wonder? I don't write that I'm a feminist in my 'about me' section of anything because, first, I'm an intersectional feminist, and secondly, I am scared. I'm scared that people will think I'm some sort of self-proclaimed wunderkid trying to say that I'm 'culturally informed' and that people may think that because I'm interested in fashion, I'm therefore, not able to be a feminist? The whole sort of 'flower crown/aesthetic feminism' is also an issue with some people. Despite reading Rookie (which people say encourages the mentality that feminism is all frills and pretty and believing in equality but that's really it) less recently, I do wear flower crowns WHEN I FEEL LIKE IT and I don't personally see it as a statement, or as thinking about doing something 'rookie'. I also read the whole Hipster Musings/rookie/Arabelle thing recently and am totally in agreement with Arabelle, and I also believe that badges and patches and feminist art is whole heartedly relevant for spreading the feminist message. People will ask what those damn badges mean. People will enquire as to why you feel the need to be a feminist. So, 'flower crown feminism' as it has been coined, I think, is not a bad thing. It should not define feminism, which I think a lot of people who disagree with 'flower crown feminism' and the wave of feminists that read rookie think is what these feminists think is feminism. Feminism is about beliefs and fighting and protesting, obviously, but spreading the message and introducing a load of teens to feminism using aesthetic which will lead them to find out more about actual feminism cannot be a bad thing. Or am I misguided? I need to stop saying feminism.
Through being more informed of feminism (here we go again), I've become more alert to sexism and misogyny that I would never have noticed before. However, when someone says something overtly sexist at school or in real life somewhere, I don't say anything because I don't feel equipped enough to. I know what I believe and I know what is right, but I feel as if no matter what I could say, I couldn't change their views. I asked a few people what they thought of this Jenna Marbles video and discussed how I thought it was problematic. Maybe it was me not being coherent or whatever but no one else could see where I was coming from. I then linked them to this video, and they still couldn't see any wrong in it. I find it an odd concept to see girls sort of accepting (advocating?) internalised misogyny, but I felt at a loss to do anything about it.
I am a feminist because it is about equality. Tumblr has made me way more open minded yet so much more analytical in a way. Transphobia, fatphobia, homophobia - all the 'minority phobias' - for lack of a better phrase - are so (for lack of a better word) - stupid. The word fat and supposed insults such as being called a slut need to be reclaimed. Neither are bad things.
Coming from a white, CIS, 15 year old heterosexual girl it might seem a bit rich. I am aware. I KNOW I don't understand truly what it's like to be discriminated against to that degree for being who you are. However, I also think that if I didn't try to understand or if I were ignorant of these problems I would be a worse off person. I'm lucky in terms that, in the view of 'society', I'm white and CIS and slim and heterosexual and that's the mould I should fit. I recognise my privilege in that.
But I almost feel guilty for being those things yet also feeling like I am required to be 'pretty'. Am I a bad person for being interested in fashion and wanting to think a lot about the clothes that I wear and whether I look 'pretty' or not? I'm also thin and especially when I was younger, I remember being called anorexic, even by a friends mum as well as classmates and stuff. People didn't know what the word meant at the age of 10 but it's kept me more conscious of how I look since. The constant comments on how I looked and stuff. It was I guess bound to make me consider what I look like myself. Obviously it's not like that now. I was/am a late developer so up till a couple years ago I was still scrawny and about 4 foot tall. Over the past year I've grown into myself a bit more. I was looking at pictures of my 13 year old self yesterday on Facebook and I was tiny. People comment way less on my appearance now but the stigma is there. I wore a tutu as a gym and dance costume and people said I should eat more (I'm not even that small any more, only by height). The constant hammering of assumption and feeling like they should be able to say that is weird. Would you say to someone say GOD you should eat less? My inability to react to people commenting on any aspect of my appearance (or accept compliments) is a downfall of mine so it makes it sort of more difficult to say something. I feel like an attention seeker in saying all this. I also had this conversation a couple weeks ago. I didn't register it really at the time but again my size/metabolism was brought up by them. I do have a fast metabolism but I don't relish in it and to be able to put on weight would be brilliant. It would make buying things on Etsy easier. I'm sure as I grow more this will change.
I don't know if I'm comfortable with my size, or myself. I wish I would think before I speak, I wish I was a bit taller, I wish I could do better in school when I know I am capable of it and I wish I was less introverted in school. People assume I'm feeble and say that I'm supposed to be 'innocent and cute' and are shocked if I stand up for myself, like I don't have the capability or something. I am shy and I am awkward yet when I get closer to people I'm really different. I say things I don't mean and push people away by turning down invites and making excuses because all that feels uncomfortable to me. I'm also known as the least 'hug-y' person ever and the least confident and teacher conversant (everyone remembers the geography tictactoe incident of year 9) person on earth and I avoid pictures being taken of me like the plague. I hate my personality yet I feel guilty admitting it.
What I'm trying to string together is whether I should I be accepting myself or trying to change myself to be what I'd like to be or asking whether it's really un-feminist of me to want to change myself but all the while believe in acceptance of others? And really un-feminist by wanting to put weight on but then again sort of not (just have people acknowledge other peoples' size without meaning anything by it, not implying something or anything? It's the same with people implying that fat people are always unhealthy, which is also baloney) and a really un-feminist concept to want to be 'pretty'?
I've probably offended a dozen people in this and I am sorry, but I don't know what I should be feeling and whether, despite believing I am a feminist, whether what I am feeling reflects it. I have been really really honest in this and I feel like I've played devil's advocate and I feel quite vulnerable posting it. Am I just trying to be a big conformist? Is that bad? HELP.
I also feel like I'm making out I'm some sort of victim. That's probably just narcissism (another bad/good? trait of mine). Oh god I feel silly posting this. I might delete it.
Awhhh lovely I know how you feel. I have so much to say about this but I don't want to spew it all out on your blog so I shall send you an email later :)
ReplyDeleteThis article is so great. I feel exactly the same. When I was little there was some guy who realized that i was really insecure about my body and he started calling fat, lots of people started doing it and since then i am even more insecure. I know i should be body positive but they ruined evrything for me. Also you know that i am in that facebook group as well and it really is scary. I once posted a reaction on something about lana del rey wearing that feather headband in the ride video because i love lana del rey and ugh everbody was so angry! i felt so bad.
ReplyDeleteThis is such a great post, you've covered alot of things I also feel. At school when I annouced I was a femiminist, I suddenly felt really embarrased because I was so young and naive despite learning about womens rights and beliving and being passionate about them, and I didn't feel I was experienced and worldly wise enough to be labelled a 'feminist'.
ReplyDeletethecoolcustomer.wordpress.com
xxx
Hollie, this is perfect! I also feel that I'm being a bad feminist when I worry about my weight, how I look, and, since I'm quite shy, what don't say/criticize others for. And never feel bad about posting your opinions, we won't judge!
ReplyDeletexx
This is so good! Normally when I try and talk about feminism it just comes out as an incoherent babble. I love your blog too!
ReplyDeleteI know what you mean. There's so many different feminist perspectives, and I don't understand all of them, and it really confuses me. :/ I totally question my own feminist perspective all the time. Thank you for putting that into words.
ReplyDeleteI understand, I think it is awful that some people's reaction to someone they consider a "bad" feminist is so awful. What is a bad feminist?Shouldn't they have a productive discussion on it so everyone can enrich their views and maybe they can come to an agreement? Calling people out for not being proper feminists is counterproductive and discouraging. When I found http://hellogiggles.com/ I couldn't believe it was feminist, and the title sort of made me want to puke, but that is not the point and the site cut ally seems quite nice. Christianity has loads of different sections within it, as does socialismm but my conclution is better to be a bad feminist then none at all, and if someone doesn't like it they can talk to me nicely about it and it can go from there. I think this (http://www.vqronline.org/articles/2012/fall/gay-feminism/) is the article to do with "being a bad feminist", but my Internet is not loading and I really need to revise for an exam...Sorry about that essay there!
ReplyDeleteI definitely don't think you should delete this post--I think I relate to it a lot and it's very well written and articulated. I think that we're all still learning about these things (well, a lot of people on the internet anyway) and it's normal to make mistakes/have questions but the desire to be pretty is taught from such a young age that there's no reason to feel bad about wanting to be pretty. I agree with Cecily--I'm not sure if there is really a "right way" to be a feminist and other people disliking you for not adhering to "proper" feminist values is really very anti-feminist anyway. Tavi wrote a good post about it here about a year ago: http://www.thestylerookie.com/2011/06/when-i-was-just-little-girl-i-asked-my.html that I find is very helpful when I think about these things.
ReplyDeleteI know what you mean. I am so tired of people writing really uplifting posts on their blogs one day and then saying how self-concious they are the next. It's all so hypocritical. Oh and, I hate how competitive being a feminist has become. Feminism is not a freaking GAME! I've been on feminist pages and there are a lot of arguments in the comments section from people trying to prove how feminist they are. ugh, it's totes ridiculous.
ReplyDeleteI always feel quite pretentious because I have no inhibitions in pronouncing myself a feminist. The way I see it, you don't have to be changing the world to be a feminist, and a feminist is simply someone who believes in equality. I suppose feminism has sort of become this... what's the word I'm looking for... ugh idk I'll just move on.
ReplyDeleteFeeling self-conscious, or not liking yourself is in no way being a bad feminist. Society holds us at ridiculous standards. The body policing that goes on is absolutely disgusting. Pretty much every day I feel awful about myself, and that's part of being a teen but also just a product of society. I just try to remember why I'm feeling that way. I try to dress for myself and no one else, and to only wear things/put make up on/whatever because I WANT TO, but that's NOT easy and it's okay to slip up and it'll definitely happen but I just try to remember why I'm feeling what I'm feeling.
I readily challenge any misogynist slurs I hear at school (hoping to start a feminism club this coming semester!), and read about feminism whenever I can, but obviously there is still a lot to learn and obviously mistakes can be made, etc. I don't think anyone is a perfect feminist. And slipping up is so completely understandable and okay. I know what I believe in, and I know I am very privileged, and generally fit into society's standards (white, cis, heterosexual, etc.). I'm also only 15. There's a lot I don't know and I lot I haven't or will not experience. But I know where I stand and how I feel about oppression and society's stupid beauty ideals. I really believe we will be the generation to change this!
Thank you for writing this post! It was very brave, and very articulate, and everything you said is a good point. I commend you!
Also this:
http://feministgal.blogspot.ca/2008/07/beauty-privilege.html
Eryn <3 <3 <3 (also this might be odd but if you ever wanna discuss this more/talk about it with someone you can always do so with me! not that I have anything wise or articulate to say. But sometimes its just nice to know there's another person to talk to.)
Please don't delete this! It was so brave to put this out there. I totally understand where you're coming from. I feel like Tumblr has contributed hugely to my development as a 'feminist', and my understanding and knowledge of the 'movement' (that's a terrible word but for lack of anything better it will do). At the same time, I still don't feel like I am informed ENOUGH to call myself a feminist, and I feel like if I 'admitted' it to the people I know, and they challenged me on it or asked me why, I wouldn't be able to articulate an intelligent response. And that scares me, because I don't want to undermine what a feminist is, because I believe that feminism is still such a relevant issue in our society.
ReplyDeleteAnd the whole 'wanting to be pretty' thing definitely affects me too. I've had issues with eating and body image and not liking the way I look, which I feel makes me a 'bad feminist', because it goes so totally against the idea of not feeling the pressure to look a certain way. I guess (and this sounds like I'm playing the victim card too) that I AM a product of modern society and I firmly believe that is what has contributed to the self esteem problems I have. I don't even know where I'm going with this, but I guess the main point is that I'm glad there are other girls out there who have the same worries about calling themselves a feminist as me. I guess at the end of the day, despite the fact that I want to be 'pretty', that I feel the pressure to be 'thin', and that I love fashion, I am still a feminist and I believe that we should be able to call ourselves that if we want to, because at the end of the day, aren't the basic fundamentals the same? Whether you like your body or not? It's still about equality, and I think that is more important that fussing over individual situations. At least it is for me, and I'd like to be more confident about vocalising and explaining that! I'd like to be able to explain WHY more articulately (or at all!) as well. Ahh. Hopefully in time. Wow. I don't think that made any sense at all, I'm so sorry.
x
This post has made my week... I only got into feminism in september-ish, and I still don't completely feel like I classify, you know? And I'm still so insecure about myself, which I know is okay to be sometimes, but it's a lot more than just sometimes. And I almost feel like I have to feel great 24/7, otherwise I'll be a 'bad feminist'. I don't feel informed enough either and can't write anything remotely meaningful, it just comes out stupid so I end up deleting it! Anyway, I just wanted to say I totally get where you're coming from. Maybe we'll get better at this whole thing soon, haha. xxxxxx
ReplyDeleteThis is really good! I feel the same! I never really voice my feminist opinions around people other than my close friends or family and I still try and "conform" to societies standards, I mean I find it hard to establish whether I want those things for myself or I want those things to impress others, so when I take extra long to put some make-up on I feel like a really bad feminist for putting make-up on and worrying about my appearance because I worry that maybe I only enjoy it because I'm supposed to.
ReplyDeletewww.frankiesimone.blogspot.com
i really agree with this,like, at what point can you "classify" yourself to be a feminist?
ReplyDeletei nominated you for the liebster award :3
http://rabbitandthewomp.blogspot.co.uk/
I completely understand what you mean! It's really hard to say when you're ''officially'' a feminist, because there will always be new things you get to learn that you haven't thought of before. Sometimes I also feel as if I'm feminist(ish) just to give myself some personality? Which is bullshit, because sexism really does get me angry, but whatever.
ReplyDeleteYou did a great job writing this anyway! x